Fall Cleanup Part 2: Beyond “Save the Stems”

By Astrid Cook Dail, NC State Extension Master Gardener SM volunteer of Durham County

This post is part two of two on tidying the garden for the fall and will go into further detail on the subject of supporting insects and other wildlife through fall and winter. Read the first part on leaf cleanup and preservation here.

About “Save the Stems”

A perhaps lesser-known adage than “leave the leaves,” “save the stems” is a related phrase intended to give similar direction about preserving perennial plants in the garden over winter. Keeping perennial plants in place after they have died back provide many benefits to wildlife – birds use tufts for nests, eat seeds from seedheads, and, as is the focus of this post, the hollow stems themselves offer key nesting sites for a variety of native solitary bee species.

Frost-covered dried flowers hanging from a delicate branch

Tall coreopsis (Anacis tripteris) seedheads in the winter garden. (Image credit: Astrid Cook Dail)

The Research and Results

Similar to advice about leaving leaves in place, general wisdom encourages a hands off approach to garden tidying of plant stems until weather has warmed and insects are active again. However, the lack of detail on specific timing of cleanup and subsequent potential impacts to stem nesting bees led NC State Extension to conduct a study to understand this issue further. The article “Garden Cleanup for Pollinators: Trim Perennial Stems in Their First Winter” provides an in depth look at how bees use stems throughout the year, with the resulting science-based recommendation to trim back stems during the first winter to at least 12” or up to 24” tall.

Close-up of frost-covered dried wildflowers against a softly blurred blue background

New York ironweed (Vernonia noveboracensis) first year stems and seedheads in the winter garden. (Image credit: Astrid Cook Dail)

Cutting Back Plants While Supporting Wildlife

There are some circumstances in which leaving entire plants in place all winter may not be desirable. When our winters are wet (remember rain?), stems can mold and flop over, which can be unsightly depending on the plant location and tolerance of the gardener. Additionally, some HOAs may encourage stricter cleanup of plants. Here are some tips (and a bit of validation!) for the more aesthetically inclined among us. If you must do some fall plant cleanup, keep these considerations in mind:

  1. Timing is everything – plants should be cut back in their first winter.
  2. Leave 24” of stems in place to maximize bee nesting habitat.
  3. Keep plant trimmings – perennial tops contain essential nesting material and food for birds.
  4. When in doubt, leave plants whole.
Close-up of frost-covered dried plant stems and seed heads

Tall goldenrod (Solidago gigantea) seedheads in the winter garden. (Image credit: Astrid Cook Dail)

Do not bag up plant trimmings for the bin. You can move them to a different part of the garden and stack them neatly, still allowing their seed heads to be utilized by birds. Or you can create a decorative framework for trimmings and create a bug snug to make a winter feature. No matter how you do so, it is most important to keep these resources available for wildlife. And if you want more nesting sites for our native solitary bees, you can add a bee hotel as a garden feature.

Additional Reading and Resources

Edited by Astrid Cook Dail, NC State Extension Master GardenerSM volunteer of Durham County

Article short link: https://wp.me/p2nIr1-8wd

Build a Bug Snug: An Essential Winter Habitat for Insects

By Astrid Cook-Dail, NC State Extension Master GardenerSM volunteer intern of Durham County

A close-up of a bug snug made of leaves and twigs, designed as a habitat for overwintering insects.

One person’s trash is an insect’s treasure? The bug snug is just that. Pruned hollow stems, fallen leaves, seed heads, and twigs are great for the compost pile, but you can also use fall yard waste to build both biodiversity and healthy soil in your landscape. (Image credit: Astrid Cook)

What is a Bug Snug?

A “bug snug” is a name for a small teepee or similar structure built in late summer or early autumn and packed with leaves and other garden detritus often gathered during autumn garden cleanup or tidying. Bug snugs are similar to insect or bee hotels in that they provide insect and arachnid (bugs, generally) habitat.

Why Make a Bug Snug?

Bug snugs are a great place for all types of important creatures to overwinter during the colder months. By using a combination of leaf litter, deadheaded flowers, and plant stems, you can provide a variety of nesting types for different insects. These are the primary habitat features insects use to survive the colder months.1 Many insects such as butterflies, moths, and beetles overwinter in leaf litter, and the bug snug also provides additional protection to the soil surface where some insects overwinter underground, such as ground nesting bees.

Not only does making a bug snug help provide habitat to insects, but by supporting insects, you also support other animals further up the food chain such as birds, 96% of whom depend on a healthy population of insects to eat overwinter and feed to their young.2

Furthermore, it can be a nice design accent in the garden if there is an area that you are tidying up in the fall. While leaving the leaves and plants intact – without trimming or shredding – through the winter is key to supporting next year’s insects, oftentimes there is a small area that may be preferred to be a bit more tidy. If that is the case, then you can make use of those garden trimmings in an intentional way by building a bug snug. Best of all, this project takes almost no time and is free to make if you have a few sturdy branches around!

The bug snug should remain in place until May, or when temperatures consistently rise above 50F for at least one week, which is the time insects break dormancy and resume activity. Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation provides additional cues to determine when insects have finished overwintering and the proper time to disassemble your bug snug. And as simply as you put the bug snug together in the autumn, you can take it apart just by removing the branches used to make the structure holding in the leaf litter and stems.

How to Construct a Bug Snug

Materials

  • 3 tall branches or wooden stakes
  • Leaves, twigs, hollow stems, and debris from autumn garden cleanup
  • Jute twine
A cart filled with garden debris, including twigs and leaves, resting on the ground surrounded by fallen leaves.

(Image credit: Astrid Cook)

Step 1: Gather all materials. Here, I have leaves, vines, and flower stems, as well as wooden stakes.

A wooden tripod structure made from sticks, surrounded by fallen leaves and grass, set in a garden area.

(Image credit: Astrid Cook)

Step 2: Position the stakes to make a tripod and tie securely with twine.

A small teepee-shaped structure made of leaves and twigs, designed as a habitat for insects, situated in a garden setting with fallen leaves and grass around it.

(Image credit: Astrid Cook)

Step 3: Fill with leaf litter and garden trimmings, alternating layers of hollow stems with leaves for airflow and to provide different overwintering habitats.

Notes

1–1 Xerces Society, “Nesting & Overwintering Habitat” 2020 https://xerces.org/sites/default/files/publications/18-014.pdf

2–American Bird Conservancy, “Insect Freefall” 2019 https://abcbirds.org/blog/insect-freefall/

Resources and Additional Information

Enhancing your fall landscape to support wildlife:

https://marylandgrows.umd.edu/tag/landscaping/

On the blog, more about the benefits leaving fall leaves and photos of insects in their different stages that would benefit from a bug snug: https://wp.me/p2nIr1-5bS

Managing backyards to support birds in winter: https://gardens.si.edu/learn/blog/providing-winter-habitat-for-non-migratory-birds/

Edited by Melinda Heigel, NC State Extension Master GardenerSM volunteer of Durham County

Article Short Link: https://wp.me/p2nIr1-6I1